Best Canned Tomatoes for Your Pantry: Top Picks and Buying Guide

Canned tomatoes are a staple ingredient in many households. They’re a quick and easy way to add flavor and nutrition to a variety of dishes, from soups and stews to pasta sauces and chili. But not all canned tomatoes are created equal. Some are too watery or bland, while others are too acidic or have an off-putting metallic taste.

When it comes to finding the best canned tomatoes, there are a few things to keep in mind. First and foremost, look for tomatoes that are packed in their own juice or puree, rather than in water or tomato juice. This will ensure that the tomatoes have a rich, concentrated flavor and aren’t diluted by excess liquid.

Another important factor to consider is the type of tomato. San Marzano tomatoes, for example, are known for their sweet, complex flavor and low acidity, making them a popular choice among chefs and home cooks alike. Other varieties, like vine-ripened or fire-roasted tomatoes, offer their own unique flavor profiles and can be a great option depending on the recipe.

We spent hours researching and testing a variety of canned tomatoes to identify the best options for different cooking needs. From whole peeled tomatoes to crushed and diced varieties, we evaluated each product based on taste, texture, and overall quality. Whether you’re making a classic marinara sauce or a hearty beef stew, we’ve got you covered with our top picks for the best canned tomatoes on the market.

Best Canned Tomatoes

We’ve scoured the market to bring you the best canned tomatoes for all your cooking needs. Whether you’re making a hearty tomato sauce or a refreshing gazpacho, we’ve got you covered. Our team of experts has tested and tasted each product on this list to ensure that they meet our high standards for quality and flavor. So without further ado, here are our top picks for the best canned tomatoes.

1) Cento San Marzano Organic Peeled Tomatoes (Pack of 6)

If you’re looking for the highest quality canned tomatoes that are incredibly flavorful, then the Cento San Marzano Organic Peeled Tomatoes are definitely worth considering.

Pros

• These certified San Marzano Italian Plum Tomatoes are the highest quality, and are incredibly flavorful.
• These items offer high quality tomatoes in a thick puree, providing a delicious flavor and thick sauce.
• Gluten free and BPA free.

Cons

• The cans always come dented and banged up, so we’re concerned about the packaging.
• May be a little more acidic than some people like.
• It’s not cheap.

We recently tried the Cento San Marzano Organic Peeled Tomatoes and were impressed with the quality of the tomatoes. The thick puree provided a delicious flavor and made a thick sauce that was perfect for pasta dishes. We also appreciated that they are gluten-free and BPA-free.

However, we were disappointed to find that the cans always come dented and banged up, which raises concerns about the packaging. Additionally, some people may find that the tomatoes are a little more acidic than they prefer. Finally, while the tomatoes are of high quality, they are not cheap.

Overall, if you’re looking for high-quality canned tomatoes that are flavorful and perfect for pasta dishes, then the Cento San Marzano Organic Peeled Tomatoes are definitely worth considering. However, if you’re concerned about the packaging or prefer less acidic tomatoes, then you may want to look elsewhere.

2) Cento Certified San Marzano Whole Peeled Plum Tomatoes

If you’re looking for high-quality canned tomatoes that are perfect for making homemade sauces, then you should definitely consider the Cento Certified San Marzano Whole Peeled Plum Tomatoes. We’ve had a great experience using this product and would highly recommend it.

Pros

• Grown in an area renowned for its especially fruitful soil as a result of its proximity to mount Vesuvius
• Hand-picked only when ripe, giving them a distinctively sun-ripe and sweet taste
• Gluten-free ingredients include San Marsan whole peeled tomatoes, San Marsan puree salt, and basil leaf

Cons

• A little pricey for a can of tomatoes
• Every can was significantly dented, which could affect the seal
• Some cans were difficult to open

These tomatoes are grown in the sarnese nocerino area of Italy, which is renowned for its especially fruitful soil as a result of its proximity to mount Vesuvius. This gives them a unique flavor that we really enjoyed. Additionally, the fact that they’re hand-picked only when ripe means that they have a distinctively sun-ripe and sweet taste that’s perfect for sauces.

One thing to keep in mind is that these tomatoes are a little pricey compared to some other canned tomatoes on the market. However, we think that the quality justifies the price. Plus, they’re gluten-free, which is a big plus for anyone with dietary restrictions.

One downside that we experienced is that every can was significantly dented. While this might not affect the quality of the tomatoes inside, it does raise some concerns about the seal. Additionally, some cans were difficult to open, which could be a problem for anyone with limited hand strength.

Overall, we think that the Cento Certified San Marzano Whole Peeled Plum Tomatoes are an excellent choice for anyone looking for high-quality canned tomatoes. They have a unique flavor and are perfect for making homemade sauces.

3) SMT San Merican Crushed Canned Tomatoes

We highly recommend SMT San Merican Crushed Canned Tomatoes for those who want to elevate their dishes with a smooth and balanced tomato flavor.

Pros

• San Merican Tomatoes are top-rated by professional chefs, food journalists, and home cooks, making them a popular choice for many.
• The balanced flavor of these perfectly peeled and crashed tomatoes makes them versatile for sauces, pizza, pasta, and more.
• The iconic brand of San Merican Tomatoes is recognized by chefs and food lovers everywhere for its consistent taste and quality.

Cons

• These canned tomatoes are a bit expensive compared to other brands.
• Some customers have reported receiving dented cans in their orders.
• The taste may not be suitable for those who prefer a more acidic tomato flavor.

If you’re looking to add a smooth and balanced tomato flavor to your dishes, SMT San Merican Crushed Canned Tomatoes are a great choice. These tomatoes are perfect for a variety of recipes and are recognized by many professional chefs and food journalists for their high quality. While they may be a bit expensive compared to other brands, the consistent taste and quality make it worth the investment. Just be aware that some customers have reported receiving dented cans in their orders, and the taste may not be suitable for those who prefer a more acidic tomato flavor.

4) Hunt’s Fire Roasted Diced Tomatoes with Garlic

If you’re looking for a canned tomato product that adds a smoky flavor to your dishes, Hunt’s Fire Roasted Diced Tomatoes with Garlic is a great option.

Pros

• The fire-roasted process adds a unique smoky flavor to your dishes.
• The tomatoes are diced and ready to use, saving you time and effort in the kitchen.
• The product is 100% natural with no artificial preservatives, making it a healthier option.

Cons

• Some cans may arrive dented, which can affect the quality of the product.
• The product may not be available in all stores, so you may need to order online.
• The can may be difficult to open without a can opener.

We’ve used Hunt’s Fire Roasted Diced Tomatoes with Garlic in a variety of recipes, including chili, stews, and pasta dishes. The fire-roasted process adds a smoky flavor that makes our dishes taste like they’re fresh off the grill. We appreciate that the tomatoes are already diced, which saves us time and effort in the kitchen. Plus, the fact that the product is 100% natural with no artificial preservatives makes us feel good about using it in our cooking.

However, we have received some cans that were severely dented, which affected the quality of the product. We recommend checking the cans carefully before using them and contacting the seller if there are any issues. Additionally, we have found that the product may not be available in all stores, so we often need to order it online. Finally, the can may be difficult to open without a can opener, which can be inconvenient if you don’t have one on hand.

Overall, we recommend Hunt’s Fire Roasted Diced Tomatoes with Garlic for anyone looking to add a smoky flavor to their dishes. The product is convenient, healthy, and delicious, making it a great addition to any pantry.

5) Del Monte Canned Diced Tomatoes

If you’re looking for a versatile canned tomato that’s packed with flavor, Del Monte Canned Diced Tomatoes with the flavors of Basil, Garlic and Oregano is an excellent choice.

Pros

• The blend of basil, garlic, and oregano adds a delicious savory flavor to any dish.
• The tomatoes are picked at the peak of freshness and contain only the finest ingredients.
• The canned tomatoes are easy to store and save time in the kitchen.

Cons

• Some users may find the seasoning to be too strong for their taste.
• The cans are set to expire in 2 months, so it’s important to check the expiration date before purchasing.
• The diced tomatoes may be too small for those who prefer larger tomato chunks in their dishes.

We’ve been using Del Monte Canned Diced Tomatoes with the flavors of Basil, Garlic and Oregano for a while now, and we’re impressed with the rich taste it brings to our meals. Whether we’re making pasta sauce, soup, or stew, these canned tomatoes add a burst of flavor that tastes just like home. The blend of basil, garlic, and oregano is perfectly balanced, and the tomatoes themselves are of high quality.

One of the best things about Del Monte Canned Diced Tomatoes with the flavors of Basil, Garlic and Oregano is that they’re incredibly easy to store. The 14.5 oz cans are a convenient size that fits easily in any pantry. Plus, the cans are sealed to preserve the freshness and flavor of the ingredients, ensuring that we have the finest produce at our fingertips, regardless of the season.

While we love the seasoning in these canned tomatoes, we understand that some users may find it to be too strong for their taste. Additionally, the diced tomatoes may be too small for those who prefer larger tomato chunks in their dishes. It’s also important to note that the cans are set to expire in 2 months, so it’s essential to check the expiration date before purchasing.

Overall, Del Monte Canned Diced Tomatoes with the flavors of Basil, Garlic and Oregano is an excellent choice for anyone looking to add rich flavor to their soups, stews, meatballs, pasta sauces, and favorite family dishes. With Del Monte in our pantry, we have wholesome fruits and vegetables at our fingertips, making it easy to create delicious and nutritious meals that our whole family enjoys.

6) Hunt’s Petite Diced Tomatoes

If you’re looking for canned tomatoes that are versatile and easy to use, Hunt’s Petite Diced Tomatoes are an excellent option. With their vine-ripened tomato flavor, these tomatoes are perfect for pizzas, casseroles, stews, and chili. They come peeled, diced, and ready to go, making them ideal for dishes that call for smaller tomato chunks.

Pros

• The 100% natural tomatoes have no artificial preservatives, making them a healthier option.
• The tomatoes are Flashsteamed using simple hot water, preserving their flavor and texture.
• These tomatoes are keto-friendly, with only 4g net carbs and 0g added sugar per serving.

Cons

• Some users may prefer larger chunks of tomatoes in their dishes.
• The cans are relatively small, so you may need to use multiple cans for larger recipes.
• The product may not be available at all grocery stores.

We highly recommend Hunt’s Petite Diced Tomatoes for anyone looking for a convenient and delicious canned tomato option. These tomatoes are versatile, flavorful, and easy to use, making them perfect for a wide range of recipes.

If you’re looking for a healthier option, you’ll be pleased to know that these tomatoes are 100% natural and contain no artificial preservatives. Additionally, they are Flashsteamed using simple hot water, which helps preserve their flavor and texture.

Finally, if you’re following a keto diet, you’ll be happy to know that these tomatoes are keto-friendly, with only 4g net carbs and 0g added sugar per serving.

Overall, we think that Hunt’s Petite Diced Tomatoes are an excellent option for anyone looking for a convenient and delicious canned tomato product. Whether you’re making pizza, chili, or a hearty stew, these tomatoes are sure to add a burst of flavor to your dish.

7) Hunt’s Diced Tomatoes with Roasted Garlic, 14.5 Oz

If you’re looking for a quick and easy way to add a burst of garlic to your favorite dishes, Hunt’s Diced Tomatoes with Roasted Garlic is definitely worth a try.

Pros

• The roasted garlic flavor adds a delicious depth to any dish.
• The tomatoes are vine-ripened and peeled, diced, and ready to use.
• The product is 100% natural, with no artificial preservatives.

Cons

• The product is only available in a 14.5 oz can, which may not be enough for larger recipes.
• Some users may find the garlic flavor to be too strong.
• The price may be slightly higher than other canned tomato brands.

We recently tried Hunt’s Diced Tomatoes with Roasted Garlic in a variety of dishes, and we were impressed with the flavor and convenience of the product. The roasted garlic adds a delicious depth to any dish, and the tomatoes are always ripe and ready to use.

We used the tomatoes in a variety of recipes, including pasta dishes, soups, and stews, and they held up well in every dish. The product is also 100% natural, with no artificial preservatives, which is a big plus for those looking for healthier options.

One downside to the product is that it only comes in a 14.5 oz can, which may not be enough for larger recipes. Additionally, some users may find the garlic flavor to be too strong, so it’s important to use the product in moderation.

Overall, we would definitely recommend Hunt’s Diced Tomatoes with Roasted Garlic to anyone looking for a flavorful and convenient canned tomato option.

8) Hunt’s Diced Tomatoes, Keto Friendly, 14.5 oz diced 14.5 Ounce (Pack of 1)

If you’re looking for a versatile, all-natural canned tomato product, Hunt’s Diced Tomatoes might be a great choice for you.

Pros

• These tomatoes are picked at the peak of ripeness and canned within hours, so they have a fresh, garden-fresh flavor.
• The tomatoes are already peeled and diced, so they’re super convenient to use in a wide variety of dishes, from pasta sauces to casseroles to stews to chicken dishes.
• Hunt’s Diced Tomatoes are 100% natural, with no artificial preservatives, so you can feel good about using them in your cooking.

Cons

• The tomatoes are canned in juice, so they can be a bit on the wet side. Drain them well before using if you don’t want your dish to be too soupy.
• Some reviewers have noted that the diced pieces can be a bit large, so you may need to chop them up a bit more if you’re looking for a finer texture.
• While Hunt’s Diced Tomatoes are keto-friendly, they do contain a small amount of natural sugar (2g per serving), so keep that in mind if you’re following a strict keto diet.

We recently tried Hunt’s Diced Tomatoes in a homemade pasta sauce, and we were really impressed with the flavor. The tomatoes had a bright, fresh taste that really added to the overall dish. We also appreciated how easy they were to use – no need to peel or dice fresh tomatoes, which saved us a lot of time and effort.

One thing to keep in mind is that these tomatoes are quite wet, so you’ll want to drain them well before using if you don’t want your dish to be too soupy. We also noticed that the diced pieces were a bit larger than we were expecting, so we ended up chopping them up a bit more to get a finer texture.

Overall, we think Hunt’s Diced Tomatoes are a great choice for anyone looking for a high-quality, all-natural canned tomato product. They’re versatile, convenient, and taste great – what more could you want?

9) Sclafani Crushed Tomatoes, 28 Ounce (Pack of 12)

If you’re looking for a canned tomato product that delivers the truest tomato flavor, Sclafani Crushed Tomatoes are a great choice.

Pros

• Made from fresh, vine-ripened tomatoes
• Delicious, red tomatoes with a pinch of salt
• The perfect texture

Cons

• Some cans may arrive dented
• Not available in all supermarkets
• Slightly more expensive than other canned tomato brands

We highly recommend Sclafani Crushed Tomatoes for anyone who wants to elevate their homemade tomato sauce. These tomatoes are made from only fresh vine-ripened whole tomatoes, with a pinch of salt. There’s no added puree, tomato paste, or citric acid, which means you get the truest tomato flavor possible.

One of the best things about Sclafani Crushed Tomatoes is their texture. They’re not too chunky or too watery, making them the perfect consistency for sauces, stews, and soups. The flavor is also fantastic – these tomatoes have a rich, flavorful taste and aroma that’s sure to impress.

While Sclafani Crushed Tomatoes are slightly more expensive than other canned tomato brands, we think they’re worth the extra cost. They’re a great complement to any dish that requires canned tomatoes, and they’re sure to impress even the most discerning tomato lovers.

In conclusion, if you’re looking for a high-quality canned tomato product that delivers on flavor and texture, Sclafani Crushed Tomatoes are an excellent choice. Just be aware that some cans may arrive dented, and they may not be available in all supermarkets.

10) Bianco DiNapoli Organic Whole Peeled Tomatoes

If you’re looking for organic and flavorful canned tomatoes, Bianco DiNapoli Organic Whole Peeled Tomatoes are a great option.

Pros

• The tomatoes are organic and steam peeled, making them a healthy choice for your recipes.
• The can is made of recyclable steel and has a BPA-free liner, making it an eco-friendly option.
• The tomatoes are versatile and can be used in a variety of recipes, from sauces to soups.

Cons

• Some customers have received damaged cans, which can be frustrating.
• The price point is higher than some other canned tomato options.
• The tomatoes may be too sweet for some palates.

We recently tried Bianco DiNapoli Organic Whole Peeled Tomatoes in a few different recipes, and we were impressed with the flavor and texture. The tomatoes are naturally sweet and have a delicate taste that works well in both pasta sauces and soups. We appreciated the fact that the can is made of recyclable steel and has a BPA-free liner, making it an eco-friendly option.

One downside we noticed is that some customers have received damaged cans, which can be frustrating. Additionally, the price point is higher than some other canned tomato options, which may be a consideration for budget-conscious shoppers. Finally, the sweetness of the tomatoes may not be to everyone’s taste, so it’s worth keeping that in mind before making a purchase.

Overall, we would recommend Bianco DiNapoli Organic Whole Peeled Tomatoes to anyone looking for a high-quality, organic canned tomato option. They’re versatile, healthy, and delicious, and we think they’re a great addition to any pantry.

Buying Guide

When it comes to buying canned tomatoes, there are a few things to keep in mind to ensure that you get the best product for your money. Here are some factors to consider:

Type of Tomatoes

There are several types of canned tomatoes available, including whole peeled, crushed, diced, and pureed. Each type has its own unique texture and flavor, so it’s important to choose the right one for your recipe. For example, whole peeled tomatoes are great for making sauces and stews, while crushed tomatoes work well in soups and chili.

Quality

The quality of canned tomatoes can vary greatly, so it’s important to look for high-quality products. Check the label for information on where the tomatoes were grown and how they were processed. Look for products that are made with vine-ripened tomatoes and have no added preservatives or artificial flavors.

Packaging

Canned tomatoes come in a variety of packaging, including cans, jars, and tetra packs. Each type of packaging has its own advantages and disadvantages. Cans are durable and can be stacked for easy storage, while jars are reusable and can be used for other purposes once emptied. Tetra packs are lightweight and easy to store, but they may not be as durable as cans or jars.

Price

The price of canned tomatoes can vary depending on the brand, type, and quality. While it may be tempting to go for the cheapest option, it’s important to remember that quality should be the main priority. Look for products that offer a good balance of quality and price.

By keeping these factors in mind, you can choose the best canned tomatoes for your needs.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the top-rated canned tomatoes for making pasta sauce?

When it comes to making pasta sauce, we recommend using canned whole tomatoes that are packed in their own juices. Some of the top-rated canned tomatoes for making pasta sauce include Cento San Marzano Organic Peeled Tomatoes, Muir Glen Organic Whole Peeled Tomatoes, and Carmelina San Marzano Italian Tomatoes.

Which canned tomatoes are preferred by professional chefs?

Professional chefs often prefer canned whole tomatoes that are packed in their own juices and have a firm texture. Some of the top choices among professional chefs include San Marzano tomatoes from Italy, California Tomatoes, and Muir Glen Organic Whole Peeled Tomatoes.

What makes San Marzano canned tomatoes a superior choice?

San Marzano tomatoes are considered a superior choice because of their sweet taste, low acidity, and firm texture. They are grown in the volcanic soil near Mount Vesuvius in Italy and are known for their distinct flavor. San Marzano tomatoes are ideal for making sauces and are often used by professional chefs.

How do I choose the best canned tomatoes for a chili recipe?

When choosing canned tomatoes for a chili recipe, we recommend using canned diced tomatoes that are packed in their own juices. Look for tomatoes that have a firm texture and are not too watery. Some of the top-rated canned tomatoes for making chili include Muir Glen Organic Diced Tomatoes, Hunt’s Diced Tomatoes, and Red Gold Diced Tomatoes.

What are the recommended canned tomatoes according to America’s Test Kitchen?

According to America’s Test Kitchen, some of the best canned tomatoes include Muir Glen Organic Whole Peeled Tomatoes, Cento San Marzano Organic Peeled Tomatoes, and Redpack Whole Peeled Tomatoes. These tomatoes were tested for flavor, texture, and consistency.

Why are some brands of canned tomatoes considered better for making soup?

Some brands of canned tomatoes are considered better for making soup because they have a higher water content and are less acidic. This allows the flavors of the other ingredients in the soup to stand out. Some of the top-rated canned tomatoes for making soup include Red Gold Whole Peeled Tomatoes, Muir Glen Organic Whole Peeled Tomatoes, and Hunt’s Whole Peeled Tomatoes.